Living for Change is a weekly newsletter that provides the perspective and activities of the Boggs Center and related organizations. Thinking for Ourselves is a weekly column exploring issues in Detroit and around the Country. The column was originally published in the Michigan Citizen.
Vigilante Verdicts
The jury in the Kyle Rittenhouse case announced he was “not guilty” of killing Anthony M. Huber and Joseph Rosenbaum or of shooting Gaige Grosskreutz during the 2020 protests against police violence in Kenosha, Wisconsin. The core of the defense was that Rittenhouse was “allowed to use deadly force, even if he provoked the 25 August attack,” if he “reasonably believed” it was necessary to prevent his own death.
Words Matter
This week the Michigan State House joined the effort to ban the teaching of ideas attributed to Critical Race Theory in public schools. By a vote of 55 to 0, lawmakers approved a bill to ban teaching “implicit race or gender stereotyping” in K through 12 schools. In a contentious session, Democrats refused to vote on the bill because those who wanted to speak against it were not allowed to do so.
Election Message
Mike Duggan was reelected mayor for a third term, garnering 75.6% of the votes cast. Headlines called this victory a” landslide.” This was no “landslide” or mandate for Duggan’s leadership. Rather, this “victory” is a sign of an enormous failure on the part of Duggan, the City Clerk and much of the corporate leadership that backed them. Only 18% of those eligible to vote went to the polls. That means Duggan’s ” “mandate” rests on less than 14% of the voting population. Most people did not vote, let alone for Duggan.
Creating Safety
This election brings far too many familiar faces to the council and city hall. They remind us that there is a lot of work to be done to move us toward a more just city.
Beyond the Ballots
Next week Detroiters go to the polls to elect a mayor, city clerk, council and police commission. There are also important proposals on the ballot, including one that would allow direct control by voters to enact ordinances and allocate the money for them, Proposal S. Also, Proposal R would create a task force to explore reparations for Black Detroiters related to housing and economic development and Propose E would legalize the therapeutic use of some plant/fungi based drugs.
Water Destruction
As Detroit settles into Fall, predictions are for a wet, warm season. For many of us, this shifting weather means an increased chance of flooding. Roads quickly become impassable, sewerage backs up, and our drinking water suffers from toxic run offs of all sorts. We are still recovering from spring and summer downpours that cost us at least $140 million.
Challenging Taylor
On Thursday the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) of Michigan announced its request for the US Department of Justice (DOJ) to investigate the Taylor Police Department because of the “ongoing pattern and practice of excessive force.” They also indicated that “the particularly brutal treatment of several African Americans raises concerns about possible racial discrimination.”
Housing as a Human Right
October is often a cruel month in Detroit. It is the time of foreclosures for overdue taxes and land sales through public auction. This year, an unprecedented efforts by public and private groups will make tax evictions less likely. Wayne County officials are trying to avoid foreclosures on occupied homes and the Stay As You Pay program is designed to exempt people who are struggling with finances from property taxes. Still officials say somewhere between 18,000 and 25,000 homeowners are at risk in Wayne Country of losing homes.
Hantz Lessons
More than a decade has passed since John Hantz announced his effort to create a vast urban farm on Detroit’s east side. The original idea was to develop the world’s largest urban agricultural business, combining traditional farming methods with indoor hydroponics. This was to be augmented by agro-tourism and, ultimately, a global innovation center. The plan promised 15 to 20 jobs in the first year, and 250 within the decade. Hantz was prepared to invest $30 million over 10 years. In defending his ideas in April of 2010, Hantz explained his motives. Farming is “land extensive” he said. Detroit “cannot create value until we create scarcity, and large scale farming could begin to take land out of circulation in a positive way.”
Where Are You Running?
The official announcement by James Craig of his candidacy for Governor was surrounded by controversy. Craig was unable to deliver his scheduled speech on Belle Isle as more protestors than supporters gathered to shout him down. He managed to say he was running for governor before he ran off to the more secure Icon Building to meet with reporters and formally declare his intentions. By all accounts the speech and interaction with reporters was less interesting than the colorful denouncements of Craig on Belle Isle.
Critical Questions for Craig
In a move that surprises no one, James Craig, the former police chief of Detroit, is set to formally announce his candidacy for the office of governor of Michigan this week. Almost immediately after indicating he was running on Fox news, big republican support started flowing in his direction. Most notable are the efforts of former Governor John Engler who is behind the “We Need the Chief” PAC formed to collect cash for the effort.
Capable of Peace
This is the 20th anniversary of the attacks of September 11th. It is the first year without American troops on Afghan soil. An entire generation has grown up with war as a constant presence in their lives. They have grown up at a time when extreme cruelty and torture are normal ways of dealing with people. They have seen a world where waterboarding, physical, and psychological punishments have been defended. They have lived with a doctrine of “preemptive war,” justifying the right of the US to attack with full force those it deems might be an enemy.
In Our Power
This week, images of FBI agents raiding Detroit City Council offices and homes flashed across the news media. Council members Janee Ayers and Scott Benson, as well as staff members, were raided in a federal investigation into public corruption. This raid comes just weeks after the Council member Andre Spivey was charged with bribery. Of the nine council members elected in the last cycle, four are now tainted with real or imagined charges of corruption. All have been strong allies of the Mayor and have steadfastly backed corporate interests.
Defund the Military
The echoes of Vietnam are clear as we watch the US withdrawal from Afghanistan. Analysts are noting the parallels of the infamous Gulf of Tonkin resolution, connived to provide legal cover for the US military buildup in Vietnam with the congressional authorization of revenge on the 9-11 terrorists. It has been used to justify attacks on 14 nations ,with 37 distinct military operations, enabling the longest sustained military engagements in US other than the war on indigenous peoples. The comparison of images of panic, desperation and destruction between the fall of Saigon and the evacuations from Kabul are strikingly clear.
Toward Recentering
Detroit and Michigan have again been assaulted by severe storms. Rains brought more widespread flooding, blocking the ability of emergency workers to even get out of their doors. Nearly 800,000 people were without power for days. Extended power outages are common place in much of the city and surrounding communities. Michigan has joined the long list of places directly impacted by the forces of global warming and climate change. Extended droughts, fires, heat and rising water levels are bringing misery and death to people and places across the globe.
After the Vote
Detroit is facing a growing divide on fundamental questions of democracy. One of the clear results of last week’s primary election is evidence of how much corporate powers fear efforts that move the city toward justice. In its report of the election, the Detroit Free Press, which opposed the proposal summarized it saying, “Supporters of the controversial ballot question sought to revise Detroit's charter in ways that would push toward a more just and equitable Detroit, including better access to broadband internet, greater water affordability, a task force on reparations and justice for African Americans.”
Living Democracies
At this writing, the fate of Proposal P, the effort to revise the Detroit City Charter, is unclear. No doubt, if it is passed, it will face numerous legal challenges, as the forces against it are committed to its defeat. If it fails, however, many of the ideas contained in it will continue to be raised throughout the city. Whatever the fate of this particular issue, there are some things that are import for us to think about more carefully.
Proposal P for the People
Corporate powers have launched an all-out campaign against the proposed city charter revisions. Last week I got an email blitz from Rev. Horace Sheffield, III warning me that “Proposal P is an illusion, a delusion and a ball of confusion!” He argued that proposal P jeopardizes city services by creating dozens of mandates to increase city spending by millions every year.” The weakness in that argument seems clear.
After the Flood
This week the strongest argument for voting Yes on Proposal P for the new city charter came with torrential rains. Much like the pandemic, this catastrophe revealed the lack of comprehensive thinking about how to live more consciously in just and sustainable ways.
Sustainable Democratic Cities
As people gather to celebrate Independence Day, we face critical questions about the future of democracies. Over the last decade, with the rise of authoritarian governments and increasing repression, no one was shocked when President Biden announced in a Memorial Day speech that “democracy itself is in peril.”