Living for Change is a weekly newsletter that provides the perspective and activities of the Boggs Center and related organizations. Thinking for Ourselves is a weekly column exploring issues in Detroit and around the Country. The column was originally published in the Michigan Citizen.
Doing Better
Earlier this month my next-door neighbor’s house was robbed. I live in a typical working-class neighborhood on the west side of Detroit. My neighbor is an elderly African American man who lives alone in his family home. Until a few years ago, his mother lived with him. His children and grandchildren live up the street. He has lived in our neighborhood for all his 70 plus years and is well known. He returned home in the early evening and found every light in the house on, drawers open, cherished possessions on the floor. His handgun was stolen. He said, “They really didn’t take much of anything, but I just feel so violated.”
Public Accountability
This week, The Boggs Center joined a coalition of local groups in suing the city of Detroit over the improper approval of multimillion dollar contracts with ShotSpotter. The lawsuit argues that the city violated a hard won ordinance requiring citizen input and transparent, evidence based processes before the introduction of new surveillance technologies.
No Peace, No Justice
The day before Thanksgiving, Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy announced no charges would be brought against the five Detroit police officers who killed Porter Burks. In response to a request for help from Mr. Burks’ older brother, police shot 38 rounds, hitting Mr. Burks 19 times. He died on the street.
Every Life
The Detroit Police Department killed two people in less than one month. Last week community protests were held to draw attention to the killings of Porter Burke and Kiaza Miller. Both were in the midst of mental health crises. Both were shot to death by police who had been called by family members for help.
On the Edge
Late Saturday Catherine Cortez Masto narrowly defeated Adam Laxalt, securing Democratic control of the US Senate. This victory, along with the strong showing by democrats nationally was greeted with relief. Senator Chuck Schumer, who will retain leadership in the Senate said the vote was “a vindication for Democrats, our agenda and for the American people.”
Protecting Our Children
We are just beginning to understand the emotional and social costs of the pandemic. Isolation, fear, and uncertainty have increased violence among us. Anger and rage seem to have displaced compassion and care in much of our lives.
Violations of Decency
For a moment it looked like progressive Democrats were going to give some leadership to de-escalate the dangerous and deadly war in Ukraine. On Monday the Progressive Caucus released a letter to President Biden emphasizing, “We are under no illusions regarding the difficulties involved in engaging Russia given its outrageous and illegal invasion of Ukraine and its decision to make additional illegal annexations of Ukrainian territory. However, if there is a way to end the war while preserving a free and independent Ukraine, it is America’s responsibility to pursue every diplomatic avenue to support such a solution that is acceptable to the people of Ukraine.”
Beyond Vengeance
Recently, a jury in Florida determined that Nickolas Cruz, the young man who killed 17 people at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School in Parkland would be sentenced to life in prison. Cruz had pled guilty to first-degree murder in connection with the February 14, 2018 shooting of 14 students and three staff members. The killings touched off massive student led campaign against gun violence. Because of the guilty plea, the only question before the jury was whether Cruz would be put to death or endure life in prison. Under Florida law the jury must unanimously agree to the death penalty. In this case, three people insisted on voting for life in prison.
Transparent Council
After six postponements, an intense town hall, and relentless campaigning by Mayor Duggan and Chief White, the Detroit City Council voted 5 to 4 to support a $7 million contract for ShotSpotter gun detection technology.
The fight against ShotSpotter is far from over.
Offering Help
It is likely that the last words Porter Burke heard were “We’re here to help you man. Whatever you want, we can help you with. We can get you home.” Then another voice says, “But right now we need you to drop the knife.” After these words, Mr. Burke moved quickly and shots rang out. In the space of 3 seconds 38 shots were fired by 5 police officers. At least 15 of them hit Mr. Burke. He was taken to Sinai Grace Hospital and pronounced dead.
Protecting Public Land
Since the end of WWII, the United States has built the largest military power on the globe. Military spending enjoys widespread support from Democrats and Republicans. With the attack on the World Trade Center and the following decades of war, military spending has accelerated. A state of permanent war mentality grips much of the country.
Dangerous Silence
The specter of nuclear war is haunting us. Vladimir Putin’s recent speech made clear his willingness to consider the use of nuclear weapons. As he insisted that the invasion of Ukraine was in defense of Russian sovereignty, he declared, “If the territorial integrity of our country is threatened, we will certainly use all the means at our disposal to protect Russia and our people.” He emphasized, “This is not a bluff.”
Development Choices
For the first time in many years, money is flowing into Detroit. New projects, from parks to the reconstruction of what is now I-375 is underway. And real estate developers, Stephen Ross and the Ilitch family are offering yet another idea for redeveloping the area around Little Caesar Arena. They are proposing a new hotel at the cost of $190 million.
No ShotSpotter
ShotSpotter is back in the news and on the City Council agenda. A broad-based citizen coalition is urging people to speak out against the $8.5 million contract to expand the technology in our city. The mayor and the chief of police are both urging the council to spend $7 million from the federal Covid relief funds and $1.5 million from the city budget to expand the technology to more than 28 square miles in the city. ShotSpotter is already in two precincts. This technology was established without public consent.
Waters of Jackson
This week, many of us have been thinking about the people in Jackson, Mississippi. Heavy rains overwhelmed the aging water treatment plant. Now the city is without safe water. People cannot drink, wash, or brush their teeth with the sludge that comes out of the tap.
Water and Weapons
Along with 11.5 million other people, I watch NCIS. I have mourned the loss of favorite characters and grown old with Jethro Gibbs. I joined the 8.4 million people who welcomed the new NCIS: Hawai’i. In a world of too much violence and uncertainty, I take pleasure in the predictable crime solving exploits of the show and its multiple spin offs. Still, it came as a bit of shock to hear a character hovering over multiple real time video screens say, “ShotSpotter” had just alerted them of gun fire in a neighborhood.
Dangerous Times
The world needs wisdom now. Each day we are moving closer to the possibilities of nuclear devastation. Over the last few days, we have witnessed the irresponsible decision by speaker, Nancy Pelosi to visit Taiwan. Her insistence on the trip seemed designed to provoke China. In response China launched a series of military drills including hypersonic missiles, naval blockade simulations and stealth bombers.
Following Chicago
This week the city council of Chicago passed an ordinance guaranteeing water to all residents. The ordinance is the product of intense work by advocacy groups, the mayor, the Department of Water Management and the Department of Finance. It rests on a shared commitment that all residents should be guaranteed access to affordable water. Embedded in the ordinance is the widely held understanding that water is a human right and a sacred trust. Chicago Mayor Lightfoot, who campaigned on a platform to stop water shut offs, said, “These actions will guarantee that the City of Chicago is able to preserve water affordability for our residents in the years to come. “By strengthening, enhancing, and codifying the measures we have taken and continue to take, we will ensure that our residents retain their access to water and be able to further protect this precious resource.”
Basic Dignity
This week Jayland Walker was buried in Akron, Ohio. In a funeral reminiscent of that of Emmett Till, hundreds of mourners walked by an open casket containing the body of a young man brutalized by racist violence. Jayland Walker was killed by Akron police after being stopped for a traffic violation. He was shot more than 60 times, on foot and unarmed. Jayland Walker was 25 years old, loved by his family, friends and community. His life and all the possibilities it held are now gone. His death, like that of so many young men at the hands of police, was recorded, graphically showing the hail of bullets fired at him by 8 police officers. His lifeless body was handcuffed.
Deciding Futures
Every day we are given more evidence of the collapse of the systems of authority that provide the legal framework for our government. In a recent article in Counterpunch Gray Leupp probed this crisis at the federal level. He said, “The definition of legitimacy is ‘conformity to the law or rules.’ What happens when those who set the rules break them, or are perceived by the people they judge as rule-breakers? In this case, the ultimate guardians of the system, who lend it its legitimacy, have been exposed as a nest of liars…What happens when this unquestioned good, this classic 18th century text, this moral reference point, gets exposed, suddenly and shockingly, as a charade? The Constitution, the presidency it established, the legislature that it legitimated, and the judiciary it created—all exposed, especially in the eyes of youth—as sources not of inspiration but of the stench [Justice Sonia] Sotomayor notes wafting through her office.”