Living for Change is a weekly newsletter that provides the perspective and activities of the Boggs Center and related organizations. Thinking for Ourselves is a weekly column exploring issues in Detroit and around the Country. The column was originally published in the Michigan Citizen.
Season for Peace
This holiday season is surrounded by sorrow and rage. Many people are asking how it is possible to feel joy in the face of such suffering. Yet the magnitude of the destruction we are witnessing in Gaza is provoking a growing commitment to finding ways to peace. In Bethlehem, a town holy in much of the Christian world, a local Lutheran Church is displaying a nativity scene with a baby Jesus resting on rubble, wrapped in a keffiyeh, to protest Israeli actions.
Each day brings new images of horror. Enduring the most intense bombing since the Vietnam war, the people of Gaza are facing a public health catastrophe as basic infrastructure collapses, food and water are becoming impossible to secure, and hospitals are destroyed.
Finding Our Way
For the generation of the 1960’s, WWII was an active presence in our political imaginations. We knew of it from the lived experiences of our parents, grandparents, and community. It was present in public celebrations and popular culture. Its lessons were many. We learned that propaganda could sway masses of people to do awful, inhuman things; that all it took for evil to triumph was for good people to remain silent; that we are responsible for the actions of our governments; and that democracy was worth defending. We learned that the extension of the battlefield into cities, towns, and hamlets was a crime against humanity; and that our weapons were greater than our wisdom or compassion. And we learned governments lie. These lessons were crystalized into powerful slogans: Not in Our Names. We will not be silent. If not us, who? Democracy now. Never again.
Opening Minds and Hearts
We are in the midst of a tremendous shift in our collective understanding of the role of the US and its military. For the first time since the declaration of the “War on Terror,” people are rapidly expanding their critique of the use of force as a means of responding to differences. The level of brutality and the magnitude of destruction that we are witnessing have opened deep questions about where we are all headed. Many people are asking if death is the only way. Surely, we can find another way forward.
Giving Thanks
This Thanksgiving I am grateful that the Detroit City Council passed a resolution calling for a ceasefire in Gaza. The resolution asks for an “immediate, durable, and sustained ceasefire” to “protect and save human lives. It condemns “all acts of violence aimed at Israeli and Palestinian civilians and mourns the loss of all civilian lives.” It also recognizes that a ceasefire is an essential first step for peace, saying that “a lasting resolution can only be achieved by peaceful means and diplomacy.”
Fake News
This week the Israeli government invaded the Al Shifa hospital. This marks a new level of brutality and has shaken the world. It is being described even in mainstream media as “a watershed moment.” Images of Israeli soldiers walking past babies in incubators, in a hospital room in shambles, have been seen by people around the globe.
These images are galvanizing people, forcing even reluctant governments to condemn the cruelty of Israel and to call for prosecution for war crimes.
Better to be Censured
This week the US congress took the unusual step of censuring one of its members. At the initiation of Marjorie Taylor Greene, a republican from Georgia, the motion against Rashida Tlaib gained momentum after Tlaib spoke at a demonstration for peace. This initial effort to intimidate Tlaib was problematic, as Greene was removed from committee posts when the Democrats had control of congress, primarily because of her violent social media posts. Among them was a Facebook post showing Greene holding an assault rifle on Tlaib and two of her progressive colleagues, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) and Ilhan Omar (D-Minn.) Greene is among the most extreme right-wing members of congress and is known for suggesting that California wildfires were caused by Jewish space lasers. Her efforts to censure were difficult to take seriously.
Other Ways
Since the Israeli response to the attacks by Hamas on October 7, 2023, we have seen thousands of people organizing for a cease fire and for the provision of humanitarian aid. Many are calling for an end to the Occupation of Palestine. The taking of life, first by Hamas as they broke through the walls that confined them, and the subsequent bombings and siege of Gaza by Israel, have shaken a world grown callous toward death and destruction.
In the face of this carnage, people of conscience are choosing to act. Marches, teach ins and walk outs, direct actions, and demonstrations are happening daily. Across the globe people recognize the Israeli government is engaged in war crimes.
Call for Peace & Justice in Palestine/Israel
As the National Council of Elders, we aspire to a culture of peace, having learned through many years of struggle to resist the culture of violence which pervades and propels society in the United States. We are coming to understand our work as building a culture of peace rooted in justice. We speak from our hearts in calling for an end to the violence in Israel/Palestine.
Changing Our Ways
This week as Israeli bombs fell on Gaza, thousands of people gathered in the US Capitol calling for an immediate ceasefire. This rally, organized by IfNotNow and Jewish Voices for Peace, is part of a growing movement of people of conscience calling for an end to violence, an end to occupation and for the full self-determination and dignity of the Palestinian people.
Collective Grief
We are a world at war. These are wars that promise to destroy ordinary people, trying to live as best they can.
The attacks last week on civilians by Hamas stunned us. More than 1,000 Israelis were killed. At least 150 people have been taken hostage, their fates unknown.
We condemn this violence. We do this with the understanding that we also condemn the violence of Israeli State occupation. We understand that violence only begets more violence. Today, as world powers vow to increase military aid to Israel, the path to mutual destruction dominates any effort to move toward solutions that affirm life.
Violent Moments
Last week I got a text from a friend in New Mexico saying she was unable to make a zoom meeting. “There’s been a shooting at our demonstration. Creating healing circles.” Soon it became clear that the shooting had been done by twenty-three-year-old Ryan Martinez. He was part of a small group of men wearing MAGA hats who confronted a peaceful demonstration called by Native Americans to resist the restoration of a stature of Juan de Onate. Onate, the first colonial governor of New Mexico, was a Spanish conquistador whose history of brutality is well documented. In 1599 he destroyed the Acoma Pueblo and killed 1000 people. In 2020 the statue to him in Alcalde, New Mexico was removed because of community pressure. The plans by officials to return it has met with strong resistance.
Citizen Research
Detroit has a rich history of citizen research that contributes to the strength and vitality of our movements toward justice. In the early days of the urban agricultural movement, people explored innovative methods of soil testing and remediation. Often these efforts combined scientific practices with a systematic gathering of community knowledge.
Calling all Grassroots!
Calling all visionaries, changemakers, and revolutionaries as we offer many opportunities to gather with us in the coming weeks in the spirit of groundbreaking events that transpired 60 years ago.
1963 was a pivotal year in bending the long ark toward freedom and justice. It is a year that gave new voice to our longings for democracy. And it was a year where the violence to protect white supremacy was without restraint. Among many moments in 1963 also came Malcolm X’s speech, “Message to the Grassroots”. The speech was delivered on November 10, 1963, at the Northern Negro Grass Roots Leadership Conference, which was held at King Solomon Baptist Church here in Detroit.
Join us as we will host folks nationally and internationally to listen to this monumental speech, followed by conversation and reflection.
Fulfilling our Charter
As we begin a new legislative season, we encourage all Detroiters to read our City Charter. It is a document that expresses the deepest aspirations of our people and provides a standard for judging the effectiveness our public policies.
The Preamble of the Charter makes clear that the aim of government is to address “the needs of all citizens” and affirm “our commitment to the development and welfare of our youth, our most precious treasures; instituting programs, services and activities addressing the needs of our community; fostering an environment and government structure whereby sound public policy objectives and decisions reflect citizen participation and collective desires; pledging that all our officials, elected and appointed, will be held accountable to fulfill the intent of this Charter and hold sacred the public trust.”
Conspiring for the Future
This week the state of Georgia took drastic steps to send a message to those who object to police violence. Using the unique RICO laws of the state, and what appears to be the same grand jury that indicted President Trump, the republican governor and attorney general are attempting to confuse and intimidate people who are organizing for justice.
There is no question that this action is also intended to de-legitimize the efforts of Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis. Her RICO indictment of former President Donald Trump brings the most cogent and forceful charges documenting a conspiracy to overturn the 2020 election.
No More Rubber Stamps
On the last day of August, the Board of Police Commissioners met to discuss the promotion of 60 officers. By the authority of the city Charter, the BOPC has the final word on such decisions. The meeting took place within the context of growing public scrutiny about the functioning of the Board. Last month investigative reports revealed that two staff members on administrative leave were being paid, even though their positions had been filled by others. The board is under multiple investigations, and one of the commissioners has requested intervention by the federal Department of Justice, alleging corruption.
Part of History
This week marks the 60th Anniversary of the March on Washington. The energy and determination focused that day has improved the lives of millions of people. Voting, housing, education, employment, health care, and participation in public life were all pushed in a positive, more just direction. It is regarded as one of the most important moments in the advancement of American democracy.
Protecting Prophets
The power structure in the US is going back to old, dangerous, and deadly strategies to silence the voices calling into question the use of US military power, weapons for Ukraine, hostility toward China, support for Israel, and the efforts to increase a military presence in Africa.
Creating Safety
Porsha Woodruff is the third victim of police use of facial recognition technologies in Detroit. Like Mr. Robert Williams, her arrest last January was at her home in front of her children, by a team of six police officers. On what should have been a normal day preparing her two daughters for school, police arrested her, took her to the Detroit Detention Center, held her for 11 hours, and seemed oblivious to the fact that she was 8 months pregnant, having contractions and panic attacks. After being released with a $100,000 bond, she went straight to the hospital to be treated for dehydration and to ensure that her baby was stabilized.
Urgent Call
In an unprecedented move to encourage public conversation, top medical journals published an urgent call for the elimination of nuclear weapons. The editorial, published in several journals simultaneously, begins by referring to the Doomsday Clock. At the beginning of this year, its hands were moved forward to 90 seconds to midnight. The editorial also refers to the statement by UN Secretary-General António Guterres nearly a year ago that the world is now in “a time of nuclear danger not seen since the height of the Cold War.”